Wed, Mar 19, 2025 11:30 AM

When it comes to college essays, students often believe that standing out means writing about the most dramatic, controversial, or deeply personal experiences. While authenticity is key, certain topics can do more harm than good. Admissions officers are looking for insight into a students character, growth, and perspective, but some subjects can distract from that goal or even hurt an applicants chances.

One topic to avoid is illegal activity. While personal growth and redemption are valuable themes, discussing crimes, even minor infractions, can raise red flags. Colleges want students who will contribute positively to their community, and an essay about past misdeeds might create doubt about an applicants judgment.

Another sensitive area is trauma. While some students have overcome incredibly difficult circumstances, writing in detail about deeply personal trauma can make an essay more about shock value than self-reflection. If a student chooses to mention a difficult experience, the focus should be on resilience and personal development rather than the details of the hardship itself.

Controversial political opinions can also be risky. While its fine to discuss beliefs, an overly aggressive or one-sided approach may alienate an admissions officer with different views. Colleges value open-mindedness and intellectual curiosity, so any discussion of politics should demonstrate an ability to engage with differing perspectives.

Complaints about others, whether its teachers, parents, or peers, can also send the wrong message. An essay that focuses on blaming others rather than personal growth can make an applicant seem immature or unwilling to take responsibility for their own actions. Admissions officers are more interested in how students respond to challenges than in hearing grievances about unfair treatment.

Its important to note that writing about wealth, privilege, or exaggerated success can come across as out of touch. While achievements should be highlighted, an essay that centers on expensive vacations, elite connections, or material success can feel disconnected from the values of hard work and perseverance that colleges admire.

A strong college essay showcases self-awareness, growth, and the ability to reflect on meaningful experiences. Choosing the right topic is just as important as how its written. When in doubt, students should focus on themes that highlight their character, resilience, and aspirations in a way that feels genuine and thoughtful. College and Beyond LLC is here to guide students through this process, ensuring their essays leave a lasting impression for all the right reasons.

Need help with the College Admissions Process, Finding Scholarships, or with Financial Aid?

Schedule your Meeting with Dan Bisig – TODAY!

Let’s Meet